Con tu permiso, usamos análisis limitados y respetuosos con la privacidad para entender qué recorridos de investigación funcionan. No usamos rastreadores publicitarios ni grabación de sesiones. Puedes cambiar esta opción en Preferencias. Lee la Política de privacidad.
Quote this valuation with its source: Fair value, Potential value and the price at analysis.
FAQ
SHW — frequently asked questions
Is The Sherwin-Williams Company overvalued?
In our latest published analysis dated 2026-09-27, SHW looks meaningfully overvalued. The price recorded at analysis is 329 USD versus our fair value of 154 USD; the high endpoint is presented separately as potential value of 176 USD. That implies roughly 53.3% downside to fair value at that date.
Our latest published report, analyzed 2026-09-27, gives SHW a fair value of 154 USD and a potential value of 176 USD. The conclusion is triangulated across multiple valuation models and weighted by reliability for The Sherwin-Williams Company's archetype; it is a dated research output, not a live price.
Should I buy SHW now?
Our latest published rating for SHW, analyzed 2026-09-27, is Sell. The Sherwin-Williams Company looks meaningfully overvalued at the analysis-date price of 329 USD versus fair value of 154 USD; potential value is 176 USD. This is research for educational purposes, not personalized investment advice.
What are the biggest risks for SHW?
The dedicated bear-case section in our report analyzed 2026-09-27 documents The Sherwin-Williams Company's material risks, evidence, thresholds, and thesis-invalidation conditions. Scenario-specific explanations remain in that section so the report does not repeat or decontextualize them elsewhere.
What is SHW's rating?
Our latest published rating for SHW, analyzed 2026-09-27, is Sell, with a published moat assessment of 9/10 (Wide). It reflects our fair value of 154 USD, the potential value of 176 USD, and the price recorded at analysis (329 USD).
Este informe aún no se ha traducido. Actualice en unos minutos una vez que la cola de traducción se ponga al día.
§1 Resumen ejecutivoEN
Respuesta en 30 segundosSell
Precio frente a valor
Precio
$329.10
Valor razonable
$153.67
Valor potencial
$176.13
A fecha de
2026-09-25
Por qué puede funcionar
The biggest upside opportunity lies in a sharp cyclical rebound in North American residential housing turnover and commercial completions, coupled with aggressive market share gains in industrial Performance Coatings.
Qué cambiaría nuestra opinión
Prolonged North American housing stagnation and commercial construction freeze causing 5-year revenue CAGR to drop below 1.5%.
We assign a Sell rating to The Sherwin-Williams Company as its report-date price of $329.10 on September 25, 2026 trades at an unsustainable 114.2% premium over our Fair value of $153.67.4
Our house rating on Sherwin-Williams is Sell. For an individual investor, this rating indicates that the current equity valuation is disconnected from underlying fundamentals, creating severe asymmetric downside risk where capital is best preserved by exiting existing positions or avoiding new capital allocations.
The report was prepared at a price of $329.10 on September 25, 2026. This report-date price stands substantially above our Fair value of $153.67, representing an upside of -53.31%. Furthermore, even when evaluated against our Potential value of $176.13, which represents the high end of our valuation range under accelerated commercial share gains, the stock trades at an extended 86.9% premium.
The main risk that could challenge our Sell rating is a sharp, unexpected cyclical rebound in North American residential housing turnover and commercial repainting activity. If existing-home sales and residential completions accelerate well beyond current expectations, architectural paint volume across the store network would expand significantly above management's low-single-digit guidance. Investors would observe Paint Stores Group same-store sales accelerating into high single digits alongside robust operating margin expansion toward 17.5% through fixed-store operating leverage, lifting intrinsic valuation toward our Potential value of $176.13.5
Sherwin-Williams builds intrinsic value through its captive Paint Stores Group, which generated $13,605.9M in FY2025 revenue. Controlling more than 5,000 company-operated stores enables direct trade credit, job-site delivery, and precise custom tinting that lock in professional painting contractors who prioritize speed and reliability over paint price. This distribution moat generates consolidated gross margins of 48.85% and $3,451.6M in annual operating cash flow. However, because this earnings power is already fully recognized in our Fair value of $153.67, these operational strengths cannot support the prevailing market price of $329.10.4,5,7,8
Captive retail store distribution network (Paint Stores Group)
Paint Stores Group operates an exclusive, company-owned retail store network that generated $13,605.9M in FY2025, accounting for 57.7% of consolidated net sales. Direct control over distribution locks in commercial painting contractors through job-site delivery, custom trade credit terms, contractor bidding and management tools (ProPlus), and consistent color matching, creating substantial switching barriers that wholesale chemical suppliers and big-box retailers cannot replicate.7,8
Brand equity and proprietary product formulations
Decades of brand leadership and technical coating formulation enable premium price realization across architectural lines, as demonstrated by the rollout of high-end lines such as Emerald Symmetry. Strong brand equity supports regular price increases, including the September architectural price increase, allowing consolidated gross margins to hold at 48.85%.5,7
Localized blending facility network and turnaround speed advantage
The Performance Coatings Group generated $6,821.8M in FY2025. Its localized blending facilities are located in close physical proximity to industrial manufacturing clients, allowing rapid custom batch reformulation and delivery within days or weeks versus competitor lead times of months, securing premium price realization and high retention in general finishing and heavy equipment construction.5,8
Recomendación de la casa
We rate Sherwin-Williams a Sell because the market price of $329.10 incorporates overly aggressive long-term earnings growth expectations that stand far above the company's intrinsic Fair value of $153.67.4
Descripción general de la empresa
The Company offers product warranties for certain products. The specific terms and conditions of such warranties vary depending on the product or customer contract requirements.
Management estimated the costs of unsettled product warranty claims based on historical results and experience and included an amount in Other accruals. The Company offers assurance-type product warranties for certain products.
§2 Caso bajistaEN
A severe joint stress test models a confluence of macro and micro headwinds: persistent North American housing stagnation depressing existing-home turnover and architectural repaint volumes, compounding raw material cost inflation across petrochemical resins, monomers, and titanium dioxide, and refinancing hurdles on $15,031.7M in total debt. In this scenario, Paint Stores Group volume contracts as commercial painters face delayed project starts and tight contractor credit, while DIY retail demand remains subdued. Concurrently, input cost increases cannot be fully offset due to competitive price elasticity, compressing consolidated operating margins from 16.15% toward 13.50%. Fixed operating leverage inherent in maintaining over 5,000 captive retail stores magnifies top-line deceleration, reducing operating cash flow conversion. Under higher debt refinancing costs at an elevated pre-tax cost of debt of 5.83% and a strict cost of equity of 9.74%, discretionary capital return through share repurchases ceases, and market multiples contract toward industrial peer levels of 17.0x-18.0x P/E, driving intrinsic equity value substantially below current trading levels.
Petrochemical and titanium dioxide inflation severely compresses gross and operating margins.
Cómo puede fallar esta tesis
Prolonged North American housing stagnation and commercial construction freeze.
Paint Stores Group revenue of $13,605.9M depends on residential turnover and completions, which face ongoing softness. An extended freeze triggers top-line deceleration 5 percentage points below forecast.5,8
FV impact
-3.7%
Revenue and EPS growth 5 points lower for five years
Trigger
Within 24 months
Señales de alerta temprana a vigilar
Los cinco acontecimientos que debilitarían nuestra tesis de inversión.
Sherwin-Williams commands an elite Wide economic moat anchored by its fully integrated downstream retail distribution model. Unlike traditional chemical and specialty materials peers that rely on independent distributors, wholesale channels, or big-box retailers, Sherwin-Williams distributes the majority of its architectural coatings through more than 5,000 company-operated stores in the Paint Stores Group. In FY2025, Paint Stores Group generated $13,605.9M in revenue, representing 57.7% of total consolidated sales of $23,574.3M. This captive footprint creates high switching costs for professional painting contractors who depend on store proximity, early morning opening hours, dedicated job-site delivery, specialized trade credit, and customized digital bidding tools via the ProPlus platform. Contractors develop operational routines centered on specific store branches, making supplier substitution costly in terms of project scheduling and color tinting precision.
The company's competitive advantage extends into industrial specialty coatings through its Performance Coatings Group, which produced $6,821.8M in net sales in FY2025. In industrial coatings, turnaround speed and batch agility serve as critical customer retention drivers. Operating a decentralized network of regional blending facilities located close to customer assembly plants enables Sherwin-Williams to reformulate and deliver custom batches in days or weeks, whereas larger centralized competitors often require several months. This agility converts potential logistical supply bottlenecks into durable switching barriers, enabling surgical pricing implementation and share gains across general industrial, coil, and heavy equipment markets.
These structural advantages generate industry-leading economic profit spreads. Sherwin-Williams delivers an ROIC of 19.87%, substantially exceeding its computed WACC of 8.7545% and moderate cost of equity of 9.5556%. In contrast to wholesale specialty chemical peers such as Air Products & Chemicals (APD), which generates a gross margin of 32.06%, Sherwin-Williams achieved a consolidated gross margin of 48.85% ($11,515.5M gross profit), capturing both manufacturing and retail markups. Furthermore, operating cash flow conversion is exceptional at $3,451.6M relative to net income of $2,568.5M. The captive network's high customer retention and ongoing store additions—with 80 to 100 net new stores planned annually beginning next year —ensure that the moat remains robust across the 10-year stage I horizon.
Beneficio económico
Sherwin-Williams generates an ROIC of 19.87%, substantially exceeding its computed WACC of 8.7545% and moderate cost of equity of 9.5556% by over 1,000 basis points. This substantial spread demonstrates wide-moat economic value creation sustained by captive distribution pricing power and premium product formulation, generating $11,515.5M in gross profit (48.85% gross margin) on $23,574.3M net sales.2,7
9/ 10
Wide
Sources of advantage
01Captive retail store distribution network (Paint Stores Group) — Paint Stores Group operates an exclusive, company-owned retail store network that generated $13,605.9M in FY2025, accounting for 57.7% of consolidated net sales. Direct control over distribution locks in commercial painting contractors through job-site delivery, custom trade credit terms, contractor bidding and management tools (ProPlus), and consistent color matching, creating substantial switching barriers that wholesale chemical suppliers and big-box retailers cannot replicate.Wide
02Brand equity and proprietary product formulations — Decades of brand leadership and technical coating formulation enable premium price realization across architectural lines, as demonstrated by the rollout of high-end lines such as Emerald Symmetry. Strong brand equity supports regular price increases, including the September architectural price increase, allowing consolidated gross margins to hold at 48.85%.Wide
Amenazas conocidas al foso
Amenaza
Severidad
Cronograma
Mitigación
Prolonged stagnation in North American existing-home sales and residential construction completions depressing architectural volume demand.
high
12-24 months
Focusing on commercial repaint, property maintenance contracts, active account wallet expansion, and adding 80 to 100 net new stores beginning next year to outperform overall market completions by 1.5x to 2x.5
The highlighted cell is Fair value when every assumption sits at its base level ($153.67). Each row and column shows what Fair value becomes when one assumption moves.
Free cash flow to the firm stays positive in the first projected year at $2.4B after modeled reinvestment of $790.2M, with terminal value at 76.6% of enterprise value. A sudden drop in free cash flow is not projected unless capital spending relative to revenue, reinvestment, or gross margin resets materially.
Under the base path, Sherwin-Williams maintains steady volume growth across its captive store network, capitalizing on commercial contractor loyalty to outpace broader residential construction completions. While operational execution remains solid, the target price of $153.67 at a 55.0% probability implies a -53.3% return from the share price at $329.10 (as of 2026-09-25), reflecting significant market multiple compression toward Fair value $153.67.
Vigorous rebound in existing home turnover and residential completions driving accelerated repaint demand.
Rapid market share gains in industrial coatings powered by local blending speed advantages.
Operating margin expands toward new peaks on strong and raw material deflation.
§7 Árbol de decisión de resultadosEN
Superado
Maintain Sell; Maintain disciplined exposure; verify whether volume acceleration stems from market share gains rather than temporary channel inventory restocking.
Disparador: Consolidated revenue growth accelerating above guided mid-to-high single digits alongside sequential gross margin expansion and store volume growth exceeding peer market rates.
Even with operational upside, the share price at $329.10 trades at a substantial premium to Fair value $153.67, meaning fundamental beats are already fully priced into the shares.
En línea
Maintain Sell; Re-examine contractor order patterns and monitor whether September price increases achieve full realization without volume concessions.
Disparador: Financial performance meeting guided revenue growth and earnings targets, with steady contractor store foot traffic and stable raw material inflation realization.
Meeting base expectations leaves the stock vulnerable to valuation multiple compression, as the price at $329.10 exceeds Fair value $153.67.
Fallo
Maintain Sell; Execute position liquidation and avoid capital allocation until market valuation reflects underlying cyclical demand reality.
Disparador: Store volume turning negative, gross margin compressing due to unrecovered raw material feedstock inflation, or contractor credit defaults rising.
Operational misses would accelerate valuation multiple compression toward cyclical peers as market participants reassess premium valuation against elevated debt levels.
Calidad de los beneficios
Earnings quality is supported by healthy cash conversion where operating cash flow exceeds net income. Working capital management remains disciplined with inventory levels controlled relative to seasonal contractor demand. However, operating earnings durability faces headwinds from rising raw material feedstock costs and the lag in realizing architectural price adjustments across customer contracts.
Métricas a vigilar antes de la publicación
01
Métrica:
Paint Stores Group volume growth
ActualGuiding to low-single-digit volume expansion supported by active account growth and contractor loyalty tools.
Operating cash flow was robust at $3,451.6M in FY2025, delivering an exceptional 1.34x conversion ratio relative to GAAP net income of $2,568.5M. Free cash flow reached $2,654.0M after deducting capital expenditures of $797.6M. Cash flow conversion benefits from tight working capital discipline and high inventory turns across the captive store network, although second-half working capital demands typically rise during peak exterior painting season and inventory pre-builds ahead of raw material cost inflation.6,7
Asignación de capital
Sherwin-Williams' capital allocation strategy balances network expansion, maintenance reinvestment, dividend payments, and debt obligations. in FY2025 was $797.6M (3.38% of net sales), with normalized estimated at 80% ($638.1M) to support existing store fleet and blending facilities, while growth funds 80 to 100 net new store openings annually. Dividends totaled $3.20 per share, while discretionary share repurchases deploy excess . However, total balance-sheet debt of $15,031.7M under a pre-tax of 5.83% will require dedicated debt service and refinancing allocations over the 2027-2029 maturity window, moderating velocity.
Sherwin-Williams generates an ROIC of 19.87%, demonstrating superior capital efficiency. The company's high ROIC is sustained by the high sales density of its captive retail stores, strong brand pricing power that preserves 48.85% gross margins, and rapid working capital turnover. Over the past decade, operating margins have demonstrated resilience, averaging over 16.0% despite intermittent raw material shocks.
ROIC of 19.87% substantially exceeds the computed WACC of 8.7545% by 1,112 basis points, and exceeds the moderate cost of equity of 9.5556% by 1,031 basis points, verifying exceptional economic value creation.
Captive retail store integration generates premium far exceeding specialty chemical peer averages.
Ingresos más recientes23,6 mil M US$CAGR de ingresos +7,9 %
Margen operativo16,1 %10 periodos fiscales
Flujo de caja libre más reciente2654 M US$FY2025
Deuda neta9463,6 M US$FY2025
Desglose de la cuenta de resultadosCómo la escala del negocio se convierte en beneficio declarado.30 jun 2026
StockMarketAgent.AI
Ingresos6789,3 M US$Coste de ventas−3451,3 M US$Beneficio bruto3338 M US$Gastos operativos−2107,1 M US$Beneficio operativo1230,9 M US$Partidas no operativas e impuestos−387,3 M US$Beneficio neto843,6 M US$
Datos del historial financiero
Ingresos
6.789.300.000 US$
Coste de ventas
3.451.300.000 US$
Beneficio bruto
3.338.000.000 US$
Gastos operativos
2.107.100.000 US$
Beneficio operativo
1.230.900.000 US$
Partidas no operativas e impuestos
-387.300.000 US$
Beneficio neto
843.600.000 US$
Resumen del balanceCómo se mantienen y financian los activos declarados en el período seleccionado.
StockMarketAgent.AI
Composición de activosFinanciado por
Activos totales25,9 mil M US$Efectivo207,2 M US$Activos corrientes6007,4 M US$Pasivos totales21,3 mil M US$Pasivos corrientes6920,3 M US$Patrimonio neto4598,3 M US$
Datos del desglose del balance
Activos totales
25.901.700.000 US$
Efectivo
207.200.000 US$
Activos corrientes
6.007.400.000 US$
Pasivos totales
21.303.400.000 US$
Pasivos corrientes
6.920.300.000 US$
Patrimonio neto
4.598.300.000 US$
Puente de flujo de cajaCómo el flujo de caja operativo se convirtió en flujo de caja libre en FY2025.
StockMarketAgent.AI
Conciliación del flujo operativo
Beneficio neto2568,5 M US$Depreciación y amortización+676,9 M US$Compensación basada en acciones+123,5 M US$Otros ajustes operativos+82,7 M US$Flujo de caja operativo3451,6 M US$
Conciliación del efectivo inicial al final
Efectivo inicial210,4 M US$Flujo de caja operativo+3451,6 M US$Flujo de inversión−2066,3 M US$Flujo de financiación−1378,6 M US$Efecto del tipo de cambio−9,9 M US$Efectivo final207,2 M US$
3451,6 M US$ − 797,6 M US$Flujo de caja libre 2654 M US$
Datos del puente de flujo de caja
Beneficio neto
2.568.500.000 US$
Entrada operativa
3.451.600.000 US$
Depreciación y amortización
676.900.000 US$
Compensación basada en acciones
123.500.000 US$
Otros ajustes operativos
82.700.000 US$
Flujo de caja operativo
3.451.600.000 US$
Efectivo disponible
3.662.000.000 US$
Efectivo inicial
210.400.000 US$
Salida de inversión
2.066.300.000 US$
Capex
797.600.000 US$
Otras actividades de inversión
1.268.700.000 US$
Salida de financiación
1.378.600.000 US$
Efecto del tipo de cambio
9.900.000 US$
Efectivo final
207.200.000 US$
Flujo de inversión
-2.066.300.000 US$
Flujo de financiación
-1.378.600.000 US$
Ingresos por categoría de negocioProporción de los ingresos totales de 2026-06-30.
6789,3 MIngresos totales
Ingresos por categoría de negocioProporción
Cost of3451,3 M50,8 %
Otros3338 M49,2 %
Datos de composición de ingresos: Ingresos por categoría de negocio
Ingresos por categoría de negocio
Ingresos
Proporción
interanual
Cost of
3451,3 M
50,8 %
—
Other
3338 M
49,2 %
—
Ingresos y beneficiosCómo la escala del negocio se convierte en beneficio declarado.
Efectivo y deudaLiquidez disponible frente al endeudamiento total.
Generación de efectivoFlujo de caja operativo frente al flujo de caja libre.
RentabilidadEvolución de los márgenes bruto, operativo y neto.
Datos financieros puntuales utilizados en el análisis del 2026-09-27.
Datos del historial financiero
Período
Ingresos
EBITDA
Beneficio neto
Flujo de caja operativo
Flujo de caja libre
Capex
Depreciación y amortización
Compensación basada en acciones
Recompras de acciones
Dividendos pagados
Emisión neta de deuda
Flujo de inversión
Flujo de financiación
Efectivo inicial
Efectivo final
Efectivo e inversiones
Deuda total
Margen operativo
ROIC
WACC
Diferencial ROIC−WACC
2016-12-31
11,9 mil M US$
1946,8 M US$
1132,7 M US$
1308,6 M US$
1069,5 M US$
239 M US$
197,5 M US$
72,1 M US$
—
312,1 M US$
—
-303,8 M US$
-307,4 M US$
—
889,8 M US$
889,8 M US$
1952,5 M US$
18,3 %
—
5,6 %
—
2017-12-31
15 mil M US$
2224,6 M US$
1727,9 M US$
1884 M US$
1661,2 M US$
222,8 M US$
491,8 M US$
90,3 M US$
—
319 M US$
—
-9047,4 M US$
6514,1 M US$
889,8 M US$
204,2 M US$
204,2 M US$
9886,9 M US$
14,9 %
—
5,0 %
—
2018-12-31
17,5 mil M US$
2322,7 M US$
1108,7 M US$
1943,7 M US$
1692,7 M US$
251 M US$
596,3 M US$
82,6 M US$
—
322,9 M US$
—
-251,6 M US$
-1746,7 M US$
204,2 M US$
155,5 M US$
155,5 M US$
9015,3 M US$
14,9 %
—
5,2 %
—
2019-12-31
17,9 mil M US$
2906 M US$
1541,3 M US$
2321,3 M US$
1992,4 M US$
328,9 M US$
574,9 M US$
101,7 M US$
—
420,8 M US$
—
-462,6 M US$
-1846,4 M US$
155,5 M US$
161,8 M US$
161,8 M US$
8480,5 M US$
15,7 %
—
5,6 %
—
2020-12-31
18,4 mil M US$
3443 M US$
2030,4 M US$
3408,6 M US$
3104,8 M US$
303,8 M US$
581,4 M US$
95,9 M US$
—
488 M US$
—
-322,4 M US$
-3020,1 M US$
161,8 M US$
226,6 M US$
226,6 M US$
8292 M US$
18,4 %
—
4,7 %
—
2021-12-31
19,9 mil M US$
3155,9 M US$
1864,4 M US$
2244,6 M US$
1872,6 M US$
372 M US$
572,6 M US$
97,7 M US$
—
587,1 M US$
—
-476,4 M US$
-1834 M US$
226,6 M US$
165,7 M US$
165,7 M US$
8851,5 M US$
15,5 %
—
5,3 %
—
2022-12-31
22,1 mil M US$
3545 M US$
2020,1 M US$
1919,9 M US$
1275,4 M US$
644,5 M US$
581,1 M US$
99,7 M US$
883,2 M US$
618,5 M US$
1153,8 M US$
-1607,6 M US$
-282,4 M US$
165,7 M US$
198,8 M US$
198,8 M US$
9591,6 M US$
15,3 %
—
7,6 %
—
2023-12-31
23,1 mil M US$
3692,7 M US$
2388,8 M US$
3521,9 M US$
2633,5 M US$
888,4 M US$
622,5 M US$
115,9 M US$
1432 M US$
623,7 M US$
-433,8 M US$
-1039,3 M US$
-2424,6 M US$
198,8 M US$
276,8 M US$
276,8 M US$
9476,7 M US$
18,1 %
—
7,8 %
—
2024-12-31
23,1 mil M US$
4491,5 M US$
2681,4 M US$
3153,2 M US$
2083,2 M US$
1070 M US$
624 M US$
138,1 M US$
1738,8 M US$
723,4 M US$
272,9 M US$
-1196,3 M US$
-2017,1 M US$
276,8 M US$
210,4 M US$
210,4 M US$
9226 M US$
16,3 %
—
8,5 %
—
2025-12-31
23,6 mil M US$
4395,9 M US$
2568,5 M US$
3451,6 M US$
2654 M US$
797,6 M US$
676,9 M US$
123,5 M US$
1656,4 M US$
789,8 M US$
1013,8 M US$
-2066,3 M US$
-1378,6 M US$
210,4 M US$
207,2 M US$
207,2 M US$
9670,8 M US$
16,1 %
—
7,7 %
—
§9 Comparación de valoración con pares
Valor razonableReport-date price
The Sherwin-Williams CompanySHW
Precio / valor razonable
Valor razonable153,67 US$Report-date price329,1 US$
Fecha de evaluación
Ventaja competitivaWide
Cuadro de mando de inversión59 / 100
Linde plcLIN
Precio / valor razonable
Valor razonable266,68 US$Report-date price468,38 US$
Fecha de evaluación
Ventaja competitivaNone
Cuadro de mando de inversión53 / 100
Ecolab Inc.ECL
Precio / valor razonable
Valor razonable203,99 US$Report-date price273,7 US$
Fecha de evaluación
Ventaja competitivaWide
Cuadro de mando de inversión62 / 100
The Sherwin-Williams CompanySHW
Precio / valor razonable
Valor razonable153,67 US$Report-date price329,1 US$
The Sherwin-Williams Company (SHW) trades at 23.8x forward earnings against a peer median of 21.8x. Its EV/EBITDA of 20.0x compares with a peer median of 17.6x. The comparison uses 4 peers: Linde plc, Ecolab Inc., Air Products and Chemicals Inc. and Freeport-McMoRan Inc., as of 2026-09-27.
§10 Industria y cicloEN
Fase del ciclo
Contraction
The specialty materials industry exhibits a capex-to-depreciation ratio of 1.55x and capex-to-revenue ratio of 4.10%. Sherwin-Williams maintains disciplined capital additions with FY2025 capex of $797.6M on revenue of $23,574.3M (3.38% of sales), alongside depreciation of $676.9M (capex/depreciation of 1.18x). Broader chemical industry capex indicates late-cycle capacity expansion, while architectural coatings demand faces demand-led cyclical contraction.7
Ciclo alcista
A bull cycle is characterized by accelerating residential real estate turnover, lower mortgage rates spurring existing-home sales and remodel activity, robust non-residential commercial building maintenance, and expansion in industrial manufacturing. In this environment, paint gallon volume demand expands strongly, allowing coatings manufacturers to achieve operating leverage across captive retail store networks, push through positive price/mix realization, and expand operating margins.
Ciclo bajista
A bear cycle in architectural and industrial coatings is triggered by prolonged high mortgage interest rates that lock homeowners in place, causing North American existing-home sales and residential remodel turnover to stagnate. Under this regime, commercial project completions slow, DIY demand weakens, and industrial original equipment manufacturing contracts. Concurrently, petrochemical supply shocks drive up input costs for resins, monomers, and pigments, resulting in margin contraction as fixed retail store operating expenses deleverage.
Tendencias seculares
Tendencia
Impacto
Nota
Aging United States housing stock driving non-discretionary architectural repaint demand
positive
The median age of owner-occupied housing units in the United States exceeds 40 years, necessitating regular exterior and interior architectural repaint maintenance cycles regardless of new construction velocity, creating durable baseline gallon demand.
Professional painter market share expansion over consumer DIY paint application
positive
Commercial and residential property owners increasingly hire professional painting contractors rather than undertaking do-it-yourself painting, shifting volume toward dedicated commercial paint stores that cater to professional contractors with custom tinting, credit, and delivery.
Posicionamiento
Sherwin-Williams is positioned at the pinnacle of the architectural coatings industry in North America through its captive network of over 5,000 Paint Stores, insulating the company from upstream chemical commodity swings and downstream big-box retailer margin squeeze. By controlling retail distribution directly, Sherwin-Williams captures both manufacturing and retail distribution margins, allowing it to sustain 48.85% gross margins and outperform underlying market demand by 1.5x to 2x. In industrial coatings, localized blending infrastructure provides unmatched speed, positioning the firm to take share from larger, slower competitors during industrial demand recovery.5,7
§11 Gestión de posiciónEN
Tamaño de posición
0%
With the investment committee establishing a Sell rating and the share price trading at a 114.2% premium to synthesized Fair value of $153.67 relative to the analysis price of $329.10, zero capital allocation is recommended.4
Riesgo
Risk management requires immediate capital preservation. Sherwin-Williams is an exceptionally well-run business with a Wide economic moat, but its current market valuation prices in unattainable perpetual growth and multiple permanence. Investors should eliminate equity exposure and avoid dip-buying until the market multiple reconciles with cyclical reality.
Tramos de entrada
Nivel
Acción
Por qué
Above Potential value ceiling of $176.13
Avoid / Do not accumulate
The stock trades at an extreme premium to fair value; purchasing shares above the potential value ceiling exposes capital to severe multiple contraction risk.
Near Fair value midpoint of $153.67
Re-evaluate fundamental risk
A pullback to synthesized Fair value of $153.67 would eliminate the market premium and warrant fresh evaluation of the cyclical growth trajectory.
Confirm structural impairment of the captive retail distribution moat and reduce terminal earnings expectations.
§12 Perspectivas de inversoresEN
Value Investor
Avoid
Trading at a 114.2% premium to our Fair value of $153.67 and a forward P/E of 23.75x, the stock offers negative margin of safety and significant downside risk.4
Growth Investor
Avoid
Even assuming consensus FY2027 diluted EPS of $13.60, the implied 10-year EPS growth hurdle embedded in the $329.10 share price is 12.83% annually, which is nearly 10 percentage points above historical revenue growth of 2.10%.1,4
Income Investor
Avoid
A low current dividend payout of $3.20 per share yields less than 1.0% on the report-date price of $329.10, while total debt of $15.03B requires debt service prioritization over dividend acceleration.4
§14 Recomendación finalEN
Acción
Vender
Sell existing positions and avoid initiating new capital commitments in Sherwin-Williams. At the report-date price of $329.10 on September 25, 2026, the equity trades at an extreme 114.2% premium over our Fair value of $153.67, offering an upside of -53.31%.4
While Sherwin-Williams possesses an exceptional competitive moat anchored by its captive Paint Stores Group and achieves a superior 19.87% ROIC, current market pricing discounts unrealistically aggressive long-term compound growth that leaves zero margin of safety against cyclical housing slowdowns or raw material inflation headwinds.
§15Your notes
Capture your own thesis, position size, and follow-up questions. Stays on this device, only you can see it.
Private notes
Visible only to you. Synced to this device.
0 chars
Sources
The records this analysis drew on, as they stood when it was run.
Analyst consensusData as of 2026-09-27 · Published 2026-09-27 · Provider-adjusted · cited for 1 figureCited in Perspectivas de inversores
Not every cited input appears here: internal calculations and intermediate model outputs have no external record, and some citations could not be matched to one.
Valuation multiples re-rate lower toward cyclical chemical peers under elevated debt refinancing burdens.
The downside scenario reflects a prolonged stagnation in North American residential real estate turnover combined with rising petrochemical input costs that cannot be fully offset through contractor pricing. High debt levels and operating deleverage across the captive store network contract profitability, causing market multiples to compress toward specialty chemical peer levels.
Persistent petrochemical and titanium dioxide inflation squeeze with contractor pricing pushback.
Operating margins dropped to 14.89% in 2018. With management raising inflation outlook and price hikes delayed to September, input cost spikes reduce operating margin by 300 bps below the 16.15% current level.4,5
FV impact
-3.2%
Operating margin 3 points lower throughout
Trigger
Within 12 months
Multiple re-rating toward cyclical industrial chemical peer multiples due to high debt burden.
Peers with significant industrial exposure trade at 17.46x (FCX) and 19.52x (APD). High debt of $15,031.7M and moderating growth compress SHW's terminal multiple by 20% from the assumed 21.0x.4
FV impact
-2.5%
Terminal multiple 20% lower
Trigger
Within 18 months
Higher-for-longer interest rate regime and rising credit spread increasing cost of capital.
Severe erosion of the economic profit spread above WACC of 8.7545% and moderate Ke of 9.5556%, signaling structural moat decay.
Actual:19.87% in FY2025
Alerta siBelow 12.00% in any trailing 12-month period
03
Localized blending facility network and turnaround speed advantage — The Performance Coatings Group generated $6,821.8M in FY2025. Its localized blending facilities are located in close physical proximity to industrial manufacturing clients, allowing rapid custom batch reformulation and delivery within days or weeks versus competitor lead times of months, securing premium price realization and high retention in general finishing and heavy equipment construction.
Moderate
Petrochemical monomer, resin, solvent, and titanium dioxide raw material cost spikes eroding gross profit margins.
medium
6-12 months
Demonstrated pricing power through disciplined price hikes, including the September architectural increase and surgical industrial contract indexing.5
Big-box home improvement retailers expanding pro-contractor discount programs and exclusive private-label architectural coatings.
low
24-36 months
Maintaining strategic partnerships with select big-box retailers (Lowe's, Menards) for dedicated consumer lines while focusing core capital investments on proprietary store contractor services.5
In the bull path, a sharp recovery in North American housing turnover drives surging architectural repaint demand, while the Performance Coatings Group accelerates industrial account wins through rapid local blending batch delivery. Supported by expanding operating margins and accelerated capital returns, the target price reaches $176.13 with a 20.0% probability, yielding a -46.5% return compared to the share price at $329.10 (as of 2026-09-25).
Directly determines gross margin trajectory and tests whether pricing increases can offset higher formulation costs.
03
Métrica:
Realization glide path of architectural price hikes
ActualArchitectural price increases implemented in September with realization expected to extend across upcoming quarters.
Por qué importa
Price realization protects operating profit margins and reveals contractor price tolerance during housing market turnover softness.
04
Métrica:
Performance Coatings Group order turnaround and new account wins
ActualGrowth in general finishing and heavy equipment construction offsetting core erosion in transportation and energy end-markets.
Por qué importa
Demonstrates industrial moat strength by converting rapid delivery and color matching into premium pricing and market share.
Paint Stores Group delivered $13,605.9M in revenue (57.7% of total sales), supporting consolidated gross profit of $11,515.5M (48.85% gross margin).
Direct retail distribution captures retail markup that chemical peers concede to third-party distributors, insulating consolidated profitability from commodity cost swings.
Operating cash flow of $3,451.6M exceeded net income of $2,568.5M by $883.1M in FY2025, yielding a conversion rate of 134.4%.
High-quality cash generation fully funds annual capex requirements of $797.6M and sustains discretionary capital returns across economic cycles.
Substantial leverage creates refinancing headwinds that limit financial flexibility.
Total debt of $15,031.7M as of September 27, 2026 carries a pre-tax cost of debt of 5.83% with debt weighting at 15.84%.
Refinancing upcoming debt maturities in a higher-for-longer rate environment will increase annual interest expense, capping equity multiple expansion relative to chemical peers.
Air Products and Chemicals, Inc.APD
Precio / valor razonable
Valor razonable251,01 US$Report-date price273,33 US$
Fecha de evaluación
Ventaja competitivaNarrow
Cuadro de mando de inversión49 / 100
Freeport-McMoRan Inc.FCX
Precio / valor razonable
Valor razonable32,53 US$Report-date price72,31 US$
Fecha de evaluación
Ventaja competitivaNarrow
Cuadro de mando de inversión59 / 100
Margen
SHW
The Sherwin-Williams Company
$79.9B
23.8x
3.3x
20.0x
65.1%
—
LIN
Linde plc
$216.6B
24.0x
6.1x
17.5x
18.4%
28.1%
ECL
Ecolab Inc.
$78.3B
29.7x
4.7x
21.1x
22.0%
18.5%
APD
Air Products and Chemicals Inc.
$62.7B
19.5x
5.0x
17.8x
0.0%
25.5%
FCX
Freeport-McMoRan Inc.
$103.8B
17.5x
4.0x
12.8x
14.8%
33.4%
Regulatory transition toward low-VOC and sustainable waterborne chemical formulations
positive
Tightening environmental regulations regarding volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and chemical solvents favor large-scale formulators with extensive R&D capabilities capable of engineering compliant, high-durability waterborne coatings.
