Skip to content
StockMarketAgent
Home›Tools›FD vs stock market returns
§ Tools / Series 03 · Personal finance

FD vs stock market returns

Park your money in a Fixed Deposit, or put it in the market. Which produces more, and what equity return would you need just to match the FD? Closed-form math on both sides, lot-aware equity tax in monthly mode, and the inflation deflator surfaced as a first-class output. No "stocks always win" copy. The tool reports what your assumptions produce.

§ Risk asymmetry

Equity returns are assumptions, not guarantees. FD/RD has issuer risk, premature-withdrawal penalties, and deposit-insurance caps (FDIC, DICGC, etc.). Risk is not the same as zero. The calculator surfaces both with their own caveats and never pretends one is risk-free.

2
Modes
3
Bases
Lot-aware
Equity tax
5×5
Sensitivity
v1
Methodology
Investment mode
01Investment
02FD side
03Equity side
04Advanced · taxation
Taxation is off. Gross and real comparisons are still available. Turn it on to model lot-aware equity tax (monthly mode) and FD tax timing.
Difference · Gross
+$1,659
Equity wins · Equity $8,733 vs. FD $7,074
Break-even equity return
7.19%
Your assumption (12%) is above break-even. Equity wins.
FD maturity value
$7,074
gross · FD
Equity future value
$8,733
gross · Equity
Difference (gross)
+$1,659
Equity − FD
Break-even equity return
7.19%
to match FD
Total invested
$5,000
one-time
FD effective annual
7.186%
vs. typed 7% nominal
§ Side-by-side · Gross basis
5 years · Before tax & inflation
Total invested
$5,000
FD value
$7,074
Equity value
$8,733
Gross$7,074 vs $8,733
Real$5,814 vs $7,178
§ Year-by-year
FD (gold) vs Equity (navy)
Y0Y1Y2Y3Y4Y5
FD curve Equity curve
§ Scenarios

What if equity returns disappoint, or surprise to the upside?

Bear
$7,623
Equity return -3pp → 9%
vs FD: +$549
Base
$8,733
Equity return +0pp → 12%
vs FD: +$1,659
Bull
$9,970
Equity return +3pp → 15%
vs FD: +$2,896
§ Sensitivity

Equity − FD difference, by FD rate × equity return

5×5 grid · positive (green) = Equity wins · negative (red) = FD wins
Equity return →
↓ FD rate8.0%10.0%12.0%14.0%16.0%
5.00%+$869+$1,569+$2,323+$3,133+$4,001
6.00%+$545+$1,245+$1,999+$2,809+$3,677
7.00%+$205+$906+$1,659+$2,469+$3,338
8.00%$-151+$550+$1,304+$2,113+$2,982
9.00%$-524+$177+$931+$1,740+$2,609
§ Formula trace
every output, derived
  1. fdEffectiveAnnual = 7.1859% (from 7% nominal, quarterly)
  2. equityEffectiveAnnual = 11.8000% (base 12% − fee 0.2%)
  3. fdGross = amount × (1 + ratePerPeriod)^(n×years) = 7073.89
  4. equityGross = amount × (1 + 11.8000%)^5 = 8733.31
  5. inflationDeflator = (1 + 4%)^5 = 1.2167
  6. breakEvenEquityReturn = (fdGross / amount)^(1/years) − 1 = 7.1859%
§ Input audit
no input silently ignored
amountused
basisused
currencyused
dividendYieldPctunused
equityLongTaxPctunused
equityReturnPctused
equityReturnTypeused
equityShortTaxPctunused
expenseRatioPctused
fdCompoundingused
fdRatePctused
fdRateTypeused
fdTaxRatePctunused
fdTaxTimingunused
inflationPctused
longTermExemptionunused
longTermMonthsunused
modeused
taxOnused
timingunused
unitused
yearsused
§ Single-product calculators
Fixed deposit calculator →Recurring deposit calculator →SIP calculator →Compound interest calculator →
§ Same engine, headlessly

Rate normalization, lot-aware equity tax, inflation deflator, scenarios, and sensitivity are reachable through public stateless REST. MCP candidates exist behind an unpassed launch gate and are not publicly available.

POST/api/v1/financial-calculators/fd-vs-equity/calculate
GET/api/v1/financial-calculators/fd-vs-equity/schema
GET/api/v1/financial-calculators/fd-vs-equity/defaults
GET/api/v1/financial-calculators/fd-vs-equity/equity-defaults?symbol=SPY&lookback_years=5 · professional+
GET/api/v1/financial-calculators/fd-vs-equity/model-defaults?region=US&profile=balanced · professional+
MCP preview · not launchedcalculate_fd_vs_equity_returnscalculate_fd_vs_sipget_fd_vs_equity_defaultsget_fd_vs_equity_market_defaultsexplain_fd_vs_equity_formula
methodology_version = financial-calculators.v1 · canonical = /en/tools/fd-vs-stock-market-returns-calculator
§ FAQ

Four things worth knowing

Q01What does the break-even number actually mean?+
It's the equity return your assumptions would need to produce just to match what the FD/RD delivers under your other inputs. If your assumed return is below it, the FD wins under your own numbers. It is the most decision-relevant single output in the panel. It converts "stocks vs FD" into a yes/no question against a single hurdle rate.
Q02Why does the FD effective rate differ from the rate I typed?+
Indian and many global banks quote FD rates as nominal APR with quarterly compounding. 7% nominal quarterly compounds to 7.186% effective annual; 7% monthly compounds to 7.229% effective. The tool exposes both numbers so the comparison is apples-to-apples. Most free calculators hide the conversion entirely.
Q03Is the equity tax really lot-aware in monthly mode?+
Yes. Each month's SIP contribution is tracked as a separate lot with its own holding period. When the program ends, lots with holding ≥ long-term threshold get the long-term rate (after the once-per-run exemption); shorter-held lots get the short-term rate. This matters a lot for short SIPs in jurisdictions with a 12-month long-term threshold. The first 12 monthly lots may not qualify.
Q04Why no built-in "stocks always win" copy?+
Because the math doesn't always say that. Flip the comparison basis to real (post-tax and post-inflation) in a high-rate / high-inflation country and the FD can win. The tool reports what your assumptions produce (including a sensitivity grid and scenarios) and leaves the decision to you. The risk asymmetry (equity volatility, FD insurance caps, issuer risk) is in the notes, not buried.

From calculation to research

Compare deposit income with researched dividend payers